Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Please Tell Me What Has Led You to Believe that Apostrophes are Optional

Okay, first of all:

I don't know if this really counts as me being back in the strictest sense of the word. I shouldn't actually even be writing this post because I have far too much marking to do and, in fact, should probably have finished it weeks ago. I'll be working on this post in between my increasingly desperate attempts to mark the last six papers in a pile of a hundred and twenty. It isn't even a "pile" because--somewhat against my will--I am marking online. Marking online is an agonising procedure I would not wish on my worst enemy.* I am about to go mad, and one of the reasons I am about to go mad will be fuelling today's Document of Puppies and Happiness.

Hello, undergrads. Did you miss me? I expect you didn't. While I was gone, did you post on Internet message boards every day? You did? That's wonderful! Did your posts contain plurals? They did! Did your posts contain possessives? Fantastic! Did you mix up the goddamn plural and possessive forms in every bloody post because you had never ever bothered to learn a single blessed thing about apostrophes?

I know the answer to this one. Do you know why I know the answer to this one?

I know the answer to this one because every single one of you is apparently in my class right now. That is why. Damn it all to Hades.

I am shocked to glance back over my index page and realise that I have apparently never ranted about apostrophes. The omission must be remedied. I am back, my dear, dear friends, so that I can terrify you into learning to use apostrophes properly. This is my quest...to follow that star...no matter how hopeless...no matter how far. I feel a lot like Don Quixote sometimes.**

The apostrophe is a strange little beast. It has been around for a fairly long time, but it is still a relatively recent arrival to the English language and has probably been misused since its first appearance, which was likely--according to this Random Paper I Have Found on the Internet, at least--at some point in the sixteenth century. It has two main functions in English: 1) to indicate that something is missing from a word or phrase and 2) to denote possession in combination with the letter "s."

Simple? You would think so. However, if undergrads treat commas like the chocolate sprinkles of written language, they treat apostrophes rather like dessert forks: unnecessary utensils that only snobs learn to use properly. Undergrads, your reckless refusal to internalise two or three simple, necessary rules is driving me completely mad. Apostrophes are not dessert forks. I wish they were steak knives so that I could intimidate you with them.

Since you, O Undergrads, should not be using contractions in formal writing,**** I shouldn't really have to explain the "omission" rule of apostrophe use, but what the hell. If you're leaving letters out of a word or yoking two words together in abbreviated form to make a single term, you replace the missing letters with an apostrophe. Cannot becomes can't and I have becomes I've. In fiction, you will often see authors adding verisimilitude to their dialogue via apostrophes, turning because into 'cause, of course into 'course, or looking into lookin'.***** Undergrads who are prone to flaunting the rules of formal writing and using contractions may also be prone to leaving the apostrophes out of those contractions. They need to realise that can't and cant are, in fact, two entirely different words. One is what you say when your sister asks you to babysit her triplets; the other is what politicians and religious leaders fling at your head for fun. You may be able to see how the apostrophe clarifies matters in this case. It is also useful when distinguishing between 'cause and cause, I'd and Id, 'course and course, she'd and shed, she'll and shell, he'll and hell, and so on. Apostrophes clarify, people. They are not dessert forks.

However, the more usual error in formal essays involves the possessive form. As I sincerely hope every schoolchild learns, 's denotes possession in English. The language is quite unusual in this regard. I know some Swedish, a language that is related to English via their shared Germanic roots; in that language, the possessive is denoted by a plain "s" without a preceding apostrophe. I believe German itself does the same thing, though like English, it also has a form roughly equivalent to "the X of the Y" ("the eyes of the dragon" instead of "the dragon's eyes"), just like French. Way back in the Middle Ages, English had the plain s possessive as well.

At any rate, yes, modern English is weird. That doesn't mean that you don't have to follow the damn rules. I am seriously doubting that the students who consistently leave apostrophes out of possessives are sitting there thinking, "The Germans do it, so why shouldn't I?"

Simple, simple rule: if you are talking about someone or something possessing something or someone, the possessor gets an apostrophe. Period. (One small note: this rule does not apply to pronouns, which are governed by their own rules. You need to learn those rules as well. I'm just saying.)

The problem is that we use that final s (without the apostrophe) to denote something else in English: the plural form. If you bother to take ten minutes to learn the difference, you are only going to mix up the two forms when your fingers are typing more quickly than your brain can handle, but a lot of people don't take those ten minutes. Thus, instead of Felicia's cats--with Felicia (possessive) owning at least two cats (plural)--we may get the abomination Felicias cat's. Just typing that made my head explode. There is absolutely no reason anyone should pluralise Felicia or turn her cats into a singular beastie that owns something unspecified. There is also absolutely no reason anyone should make this mistake when the plural form of a word differs substantially from its singular form. For instance, I have seen students writing about "the families secret" instead of "the family's secret." Ow. My brain.

Please learn this rule. It is simple. It is effective. If you know it, I shall have fewer reasons to scream and hit things.

Note of interest: the insertion of an apostrophe into a plural is prevalent enough that the error has its own name: the greengrocer's (or greengrocers') apostrophe. This name has come about because grocers are unfortunately prone to selling apple's, pear's, carrot's, and other maddeningly mangled pluralised fruit and vegetables (or, perhaps, vegetable's).

I have had students who consistently mix up the plural and possessive forms and others who use the apostrophes randomly, sometimes sticking them into possessives and sometimes into plurals. Others simply don't use apostrophes at all, ever. I realise that this error goes back hundreds of years, but I still blame the Internet.****** My dear, dear students, do you know how tired I get of typing, "Apostrophes are your friends. Please do not neglect or misuse them. Please read up on the difference between plurals and possessives"? I get almost as tired as I get of typing, "Avoid discussing authorial intent," "Please double space all university essays," "What is the significance of this observation?", and "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARGH." That is how bleeding tired I get.

Another source of confusion is the plural possessive and/or the possessive form of words ending in s. This issue is a controversial one, and for once, I am not going to stand up and declare that my way of approaching it is the right way, mostly because everybody disagrees so strenuously on what the rule actually is that I really don't know what is true any more.******* However, I'll eventually reveal my favourite version of the rule. I do think you need to pick a version and stick with it.

The guy over at Motivated Grammar has summarised the issue succinctly; his rant is worth a read. Basically, the debate is over how to make words ending in s possessive. Such words include singular nouns such as dress, plural nouns such as puppies, surnames such as Dickens, first names such as James, and historical first names such as Jesus. The basic rule, and the one to which I try to stick, is that singular nouns (including proper nouns) ending in s are made possessive with 's, whereas plural nouns ending in s are made possessive with ' alone. Therefore, the list above gives us the following possessives: dress's, puppies', Dickens's, James's, and Jesus's. I like this rule. It is easy to remember. However, as the Motivated Grammar guy informs us, there are several possible variations on this rule; some people advocate using the plain ' for all names, for names that would be difficult to pronounce with 's, or for ancient names such as Jesus and Moses. My personal belief is that these variations make things too freaking difficult, but I'm willing to accept them if you follow a given rule consistently. I am not willing to accept dress' as the possessive of dress. Singular non-proper nouns ending in s are subject to the same rules as singular non-proper nouns not ending in s.

However--darling undergrads--none of the variations allows for Dicken's being the possessive form of Dickens. I have even seen Mr. Dickens's name itself--neither pluralised, which would properly be Dickenses, or as a possessive--being written as Dicken's (as in, "Charles Dicken's is the author of Great Expectations"). Despite the fact that common sense would seem to indicate the SHEER UNMITIGATED FOLLY of this error, people still make it.

I realise that in order to follow these rules consistently, you will have to spend a few minutes proofreading each essay you write. My heart bleeds for you, albeit not really all that much. Remember: proofreading may be a minor inconvenience for you, but if you do it, and do it well, you will improve your markers' lives immeasurably. You have to read only your essay. Your markers have to read your essay and the essays written by all your classmates. When thirty-five students in a class of fifty do not understand how to use apostrophes, tears happen.

I am now finished the six essays I mentioned at the beginning of this document. I believe four of the six students made apostrophe errors. I am going to go sit in a corner and wail softly now. Go forth, young undergrads. Go forth and apostrophise.********

*Unless, of course, my worst enemy were a Batman plagiarist, which, to be frank, he or she probably is.
**The rest of the bridge of "The Impossible Dream" is even more appropriate here, actually.***
***Guess what I just did? I just played "The Impossible Dream" on the pennywhistle so that I wouldn't have to go back to marking. Unfortunately, now I really have to go back to marking, and my neighbours probably want to kill me.
****Even though you bloody well do.
*****Unless the author is Stephen King, at which point looking becomes lookin. We generally just let Stephen King do whatever the hell he wants.
******Plus possibly the greengrocers.
*******Sob.
********In all senses of the word. Look it up. It's an interesting word.

61 comments:

Stefan said...

You're back!

Usually I try to take it easy with the correction of typos others make on the internet, but in this case I think they're actual harmful to the understanding of your readers. In the paragraph with the "Motivated Grammar" link you need to replace a few "plurals" with "possessives."

Fun fact: "hobby's" is the correct plural of "hobby"... in Dutch.

I just did a test on this website, and I don't think I quite remember the rules governing this in Dutch. I still had a score of 92%.

What's the upshot of this? All the greengrocers must be Dutch ;)

Kem said...

Thanks, Stefan. I actually encourage people to point out my typos because they are just so freaking embarrassing. (I do proofread, but I miss stuff. Everybody does. What I object to is people who don't proofread at all and thus miss EVERYTHING.) In this particular case, I knew I had probably committed the plural/possessive blunder at least once. For some reason, I am as prone to mixing up the words "plural" and "possessive" as my students are to mixing up actual plurals and possessives. I hope I've corrected all the errors now, and I really wish that "possessivise" were a word.

Richard Lindberg said...

I look forward to your guidance. The temporally well-spaced posts are most effective.

Kem said...

Richard: Well, see, I just popped into my TARDIS to effect some repairs, and I thought I was only going to be gone five minutes, but I overshot my landing and ended up two years in the future. I couldn't even go back and fix the error, as that would have meant crossing my personal timeline. Damn time vortex.

Richard Lindberg said...

Typical for a type 40. I saw a type 102 for sale on Craigslist. By the time I called it was gone.

Kem said...

DAMN IT! I'll bet it was the Master again. I sometimes think he spends half his time on Craigslist. And now it's going to be all diabolic laughter and taking over the universe and my-TARDIS-is-more-sentient-than-yours, and someone will create a paradox, and I STILL won't be able to blog regularly. Poo.

Richard Lindberg said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Richard Lindberg said...

Villiar, Villiar, Villiar. I have got out my lawn chair and cooler to better watch Kem deal with that slap in the face.

Kem said...

Richard Lindberg: villiar was apparently leaving similar comments all over the site. I HAVE DESTROYED THEM. Actually, I choose to believe that the irony was simply too much for them, and they spontaneously combusted.

John said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Richard Lindberg said...

If these links appears on other comments, I would suspect the work of the Mechanical Turk. This is the type of evil spawned by him.

Have you noticed the red boxes showing up around the US? Are they a new type TARDIS or just a new appearance to fit modern times? They have a door on the front that would open to those with the correct key.

I have let my subscription to Popular Temporality lapse so am not up on the latest.

Janvi said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
sir kodak said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Sir sheamus said...

Job well done guys, quality information.
scholarships for high school seniors

elmer said...

Well, it is really optional because you will only use apostrophes when it is needed. There is a rule on how and when to use them. Even a single apostrophe can mar your writings if it will be placed wrongly.

best essay writing service reviews

BARTHOLO MEW said...

Congrats on your progress and I expect it is a trance.
dissertation proposal background

Harry Parker said...

It is really informative and attractive post. I will recommend it to others . Your work is really being appreciated.
best essay writing service

Shopnerkotha said...

Personal essay that are written for college admission are tough and designed to be a challenging assignments because you have to put together all knowledge about you along with the mentioning all your talents, personal achievements and goals.We are here to help you over here.

Carol A Brown said...

That doesn't mean that you don't have to follow the damn rules.this site I am seriously doubting that the students who consistently leave apostrophes out of possessives are sitting there thinking.

Jean Summers said...

This post reminds of my librarian in college. She told me that some grammar online are questionable. So, this post affirm to her opinion.
Now, I should be thankful to her and you for always reminding us the right use of Apostrophes and proper usage of grammar.
from students ramblingz

AVAN Daez said...

nice post...

FRANCISCO Dake said...

What a terrific sounding book - the water cycle is cool in and of itself and a book which teaches it in such a fun poetic way is mega-cool.

FRANCISCO Dake said...

What a terrific sounding book - the water cycle is cool in and of itself and a book which teaches it in such a fun poetic way is mega-cool.
cheap-essay-writing-services
custom-paper-writing
Accounts Software For Small Business

Lorraine Santos said...

Can we blame text messaging for taking apostrophes and other symbols for granted?

alex said...

Super-Duper site! I am loving it!! Will come back again - taking you feeds also, Thanks.
Online Writing Services

Andrew Milne said...

Awesome!. This post what exacly im looking for. This is what always happened forgetting something in an essay. Even in a single dot is counted also every apostrophe is counted as well. Almost all want to be a essay writers but some only are good to make this on top. Some are dropped and some are passed. but then Thanks for your post! Expressing a feeling in an essay is good. Make you feel okay and sometimes when you read you make your own self laugh!

Ava Kemp said...

As my mother tongue is Russian, I feel very difficult when I deal with apostrophe and commas in English writing. I have been told by teacher that reading habit will improve my English.

Erica Palm said...

Exactly the article I needed to stumble on as I start my vacation this week. Also, working online as an online accountant or online bookkeeper are limited by only two things: what you charge and how many hours you have available to do the online work. college essays

Jackson said...

Very interesting blog. Thanks for this blog.

essay writing service australia
essay writing canada

Eza dsoc said...

It's not my very first time to visit this blog; I’m visiting this daily and acquire superb info from here day by day. free tutor online

drove man said...

The means you worn it, it peeps as if "shareholders" is a plural possessive, yet clearly it's valid of buy college papers a genuine plural - which does NAY exact an apostrophe.

Sophia Mike said...

Great post very nice information about essay writing i have taken some needy information here very helpful here. Good work.

Thesis services at affordable prices

bruce said...

we usually write assay but we dont know how so to get essay writing help..there are some of website available that are providing these king of service online..they also help to understand the essay that we are writing about.

robin hood said...

Inconceivable points. Sound arguments. Keep going the truly amazing work.essay

Amy Charles said...

I look forward to your guidance. The temporally well-spaced posts are most effective.
essay writing service

Amy Charles said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
olivia marina said...

I am visiting this site first time, this article has nice informative..

Best Writing Service UK

Hamza Shahzad Shahzad said...

This is such good advice! And it gives me comfort to know another writer who doesn't write systematically same amount of time each day.
Cereb

Paul Lewis said...

Thanks so much for this wonderful website as well as this post. This post is the kind of thing That keeps me on track through.
Essay Writing

Apex Essays said...

Appreciated Post!,
I reached here randomly surfing over the net. I found this post very attractive. I love it to get some information regarding the Assignment Writing Service Write My Essay Online Custom Essay Writing Professional USA Custom Essay Writing service

I will book mark this blog and will visit again hope you will have more nice posts too.

Cheers,

Anand Aggarwal said...

Great post i read your article is superb . This is given good information , We are givening Fast-essay.com offers the Best Essay Writing Services in UK and USA. Whether you need help for writing a report, we are here for all your paper writing needs. If you want to know more Please Click Here
Custom essay discounts

Tutorsindia said...

Good stuff.. thank you so much
Essay writing

ashfaq ahmed said...

It is really a nice step for helping the students. It really helps me .
Now student can get essay writing help form us.. It would make their study easier..
get your homework help from here!!!!!

moon akondo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
moon akondo said...

I read your blog very carefully. Learning how to write an essay can be a maddening, exasperating process, but it doesn't have to be. If you know the essay writing steps and understand what to do, writing can be easy. essay editing service

Peter Cummins said...

Wow!! i am very impressed with your lovely post.. I am so glad to left comment on this..This has been a so interesting read, would love to read more here….
essay writing

Albert einstien said...

I do not have words to praise your blog, am quite impressed from your website and wanna see more on this soon, so provide more information this is my special request to you. http://wiki-articles.net

Carol J Loomis said...

These guiding steps are very helpful for students who lack writing skills.
thanks for sharing.
Assignments Essays Writing

Ebin Mathew said...

It is a very informative article and we are always looking forward for getting this kind of information. Admission essay writing service

Ellie Thomos said...

I'm currently essay writing . Your experience is a very useful guide!

Zaki Anwar said...

This is really great information found here, I really like your blog. Thanks very much for the share. Keep posting.
Workers Compensation
Pain Treatments
Botox Injections
Discography
Epidural Injections
Epidural Lysis Procedure
Facet Blocks
Intercostal Nerve Blocks
Intrathecal Pump Therapy
Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy
Intercostal Nerve Blocks
Joint Injections
Platelet Rich Plasma
Percutaneous Discectomy
P-STIM
Racz Epidural Neurolysis
Radiofrequency Lesioning
Selective Nerve Root Blocks
Spinal Cord Stimulation
Sympathetic Nerve Blocks
Vertebroplasty
Pain Locations
Arm Pain
Abdominal Pain
Back Pain

Stem Cell Therapy said...

Nice Post. It’s really a very good article. I noticed all your important points. Thanks 
Platelet Rich Plasma Therapy
Elbow Surgery
Hip Replacement Surgery
Shoulder Surgery
Knee Replacement Surgery
Stem Cell Therapy

Stem Cell Therapy said...

Nice Post. It’s really a very good article. I noticed all your important points. Thanks 
Platelet Rich Plasma Therapy
Elbow Surgery
Hip Replacement Surgery
Shoulder Surgery
Knee Replacement Surgery
Stem Cell Therapy

KateBannet said...

I think that if much depends on mark and you are not sure that you are going to do your best in essay writing, Then order it is the best way uk.essay-writing-place.com

Vitalya Kotov said...

I am a big fan of these essay plans thank you I will collect them all here http://essay-box.org/

Elmina Kenley said...

I am exceptionally awed with your dazzling post.. I am so happy to left remark on this..This has been a so fascinating read, would love to peruse more here Law Essay Writing Help

keyword tool said...

I am really glad to come across of your blog post on essay writing. I personally think that https://livepaperhelp.com can use the information provided by you.

Patty Green said...

I enjoyed reading your post! That was really interesting! Apostrophes are not less important than everything else in a language. Personally I'm not always sure in my grammar, so when I need a serious paper to be written I prefer to hire specialists, like from here: https://writemyessayonline.com/write-my-paper-cheap.html.

Herry Johnson said...

We are serving in custom paper writing services, you can get our opportunity to choose the term paper writing service. Here are also options for the custom essay writing services and cheap custom essay writing services.

Words Doctorate said...

Words Doctorate is providing PhD Thesis, Dissertation and Research related support for PhD Students-all stream.
PhD and Master Thesis & Dissertation Writing Service , We serve students globally in all subjects,Provide completed solutions and online Guidance by PhD Holders.

PhD Thesis Writing Services
Dissertation Writing Services
Research Paper Writing Services
M.tech Thesis Writing Services

somine said...

we claim our self to be the best essay writing company based on our terrific track record of serving students with plagiarism free quality essays, helping them achieve top grades.